Skip to content

Menu

HomeAboutServicesContact
Kean Miller LLP logo

Louisiana Law Blog

Insight and Information on Louisiana Law, Litigation, and Legal Culture

Brought to you by Kean Miller counsel who serve the legal needs of local, regional, and national companies.
Home » Choice of Law Provisions: Cheap Insurance Against the Unpredictable

Choice of Law Provisions: Cheap Insurance Against the Unpredictable

By Daniel Stanton on December 16, 2015
Posted in Admiralty and Maritime

crew boat

Choice-of-law provisions can be simple, single-sentence contract clauses that provide some certainty to disputes that may arise out of a contractual relationship. One such way that these clauses enhance the predictability of disputes is by limiting the remedies available to the parties to the contract to those available under the chosen law. This can be particularly useful when the work contemplated by a contract may occur in multiple states or on the waters adjacent to multiple states. A recent decision by the Eastern District of Louisiana in Cheramie Marine, LLC v. Freedom Well Services, LLC, 2015 WL 7306438 (E.D. La. 11/19/15) highlights the simplicity and usefulness of choice-of-law provisions in resolving disputes, and limiting exposure to damages.

The facts before the court in Cheramie Marine were all too common in our current energy climate: Cheramie Marine had provided a vessel under charter to Freedom Well who became unable to pay for the services of the vessel. After unsuccessfully attempting to recover the amounts owed through negotiations, Cheramie filed suit. But, in its suit Cheramie Marine sought recovery of not only the principal sum, but also attorneys’ fees under Louisiana’s Open Account Statute and civil penalties under Louisiana’s Misapplication of Payments Statute. Under the Louisiana Open Account Statute, a party is entitled to recover reasonable attorneys’ fees incurred in pursuit of a debt, and under the Misapplication of Payments Statute, civil penalties in an amount up to the amount of the underlying debt can be awarded against the debtor party. And while Freedom Well did not dispute that it owed Cheramie Marine for the services of its vessel, Cheramie Marine’s additional claims – if legally available – could have easily doubled the amount of any judgment rendered against Freedom Well. Accordingly, Freedom Well disputed Cheramie Marine’s ability to recover these additional items of damages.

Freedom Well’s primary argument relied on a simple choice-of-law provision in the charter agreement executed by Cheramie Marine and Freedom Well: “The Agreement shall be governed by and interpreted in accordance with General Maritime Law . . . .” And because these additional damages sought by Cheramie Marine were provided for by Louisiana statutory law, they could not be recovered in an action governed by General Maritime Law. The Court found that the choice-of-law provision was valid, and therefore, Cheramie Marine’s suit was governed by general maritime law. On this foundation, the Court was then able to rely on precedent from the Fifth Circuit denying the recovery of attorneys’ fees under state statutes in actions governed by general maritime law. In considering Cheramie Marine’s claim for civil penalties, the Court stated that Cheramie Marine had provided it with “no case in which a court allowed for the recovery of civil penalties under Louisiana’s Misapplication of Payments Statute for failure to pay pursuant to a maritime contract governed by the general maritime law.” Accordingly, the Court denied Cheramie Marine’s request for civil penalties as well.

While the case of Cheramie Marine, LLC v. Freedom Well Services, LLC represents a very simple application of a choice-of-law provision, it is important to note that the simplicity, and swift resolution of the case is partly a result of the existence of the choice-of-law provision. While a similar result may still have been achieved at a later date, the cost to get to that result would have been much greater for both parties. Furthermore, should the Court have found that the dispute was governed by some law other than general maritime law, Freedom Well may have been subject to substantial fees and penalties that it did not bargain for when it entered into the charter agreement. Cheramie Marine, LLC v. Freedom Well Services, LLC therefore stands as an effective demonstration of the predictability that can be added to the resolution of contractual disputes by the inclusion of a simple choice-of-law provision.

 

Tags: Cheramie Marine, Choice of Law provisions, choice-of-law, LLC, LLC v. Freedom Well Services, Louisiana, Misapplication of Payments Statutes, Open Account Statute
Print:
Email this postTweet this postLike this postShare this post on LinkedIn
Related Posts
Wind Park Ocean
BOEM Begins Key Environmental Assessment In Preparation for Offshore Wind Development in the GOM
January 13, 2022
The-approach-to-foreign-trade-policy-needs-to-change
The Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP): The Agreement that Promises to Reshape the International Trade Landscape
November 30, 2020
Vicksburg Riverboat Casino
Vicksburg MS, United States - October 2, 2012: Docked Riverboat Casino is major attraction in historic Vicksburg, Mississippi.
Jones Act Vessel Status Update: The Louisiana Supreme Court Finds Riverboat Casino is not a Vessel in Navigation
February 11, 2020

ABOUT THIS BLOG

At Kean Miller, we deliver more than words.  We provide meaningful counsel you can count on.

Read More

Blog Authors Show/Hide

  • Alan J. Berteau
  • Matthew Smith
  • Mallory Fuller
  • Mark Mese
  • John Miller
  • Mary Kathryn Gimber
  • Matthew Meiners
  • Maureen Harbourt
  • Louis Grossman
  • Michael deBarros
  • Michael Lowe
  • Linda Rodrigue
  • Katherine King
  • Katie Bell
  • Katilyn Hollowell
  • Kevin Curry
  • Kyle Polozola
  • Linda Clark
  • Lana Crump
  • Lauren Guichard
  • Lauren Rucinski
  • Lee Vail
  • Linda Akchin
  • Michael McGlone
  • Troy Charpentier
  • Terry Mccay
  • Todd Rossi
  • Tod Everage
  • Charles McCowan
  • Trippe Hawthorne
  • Tyler Kostal
  • Sonny Chastain
  • Victor Suane
  • William Huguet
  • William Kolarik
  • Stephen Hanemann
  • Pamela Mascari
  • Phyllis Sims
  • Rachel Scarafia
  • Randy Cangelosi
  • J. Randy Young
  • Richard McConnell
  • Robert Schmidt
  • Steven Boutwell
  • Scott Huffstetler
  • Sean McLaughlin
  • Karen Fontana Young
  • Adrienne Wood
  • Charles Talley
  • Brian Carnie
  • Brian Lindsey
  • Carey Messina
  • Carrie Tournillon
  • Charles McCowan
  • Chauvin Kean
  • Chelsea Caswell
  • Bradley Myers
  • Claire Juneau
  • Claire Zeringue
  • Crystal Burkhalter
  • Daniel Stanton
  • Dean Cazenave
  • Alexandra Rossi
  • Amanda Bourgeois
  • Amanda Collura-Day
  • Amanda Lowe
  • Ambrose Stearns, Jr.
  • Angela Adolph
  • G. Blane Clark
  • Thomas Bourgeois
  • Ben Jumonville
  • Robert Vincent
  • David Whitaker
  • Deborah Juneau
  • Jourdan Curet
  • Hattie Guidry
  • James Silverstein
  • Jason Brown
  • Jason Cashio
  • Jaye Calhoun
  • Jeffrey Boudreaux
  • Jennifer Thomas
  • Jessica Engler
  • Jill Gautreaux
  • Gregory Anding
  • R. Devin Ricci
  • M. Dwayne Johnson
  • A. Edward Hardin, Jr.
  • J Eric Lockridge
  • Erin Kilgore
  • Esteban Herrera
  • Forrest Guedry
  • Georgia Ainsworth
  • Glenn Farnet
  • Zoe Vermeulen

STAY CONNECTED

RSS LinkedIn Facebook

TOPICS

ARCHIVES


RECENT UPDATES

  • Court Provides Reminder to Insureds (Even Additional Insureds) to Provide Early Notice to Insurers to Maximize Policy Benefits
  • Fifth Circuit Finds That Individual Arbitration Agreements Bar Notice of FLSA Collective Action
  • Important New U.S. Supreme Court Opinion Holding Prejudice No Longer Required To Show Waiver Of Arbitration Agreements
  • Supreme Court to Review FLSA Claim By Highly Compensated Offshore Employee
  • Louisiana Public Service Commission – Electric Utility Regulation – Recent and Current Topics

Louisiana Law Blog

The publisher of this Web Blog is:
Erin L. Kilgore, Attorney at Law
PO Box 3513
Baton Rouge, Louisiana 70821
Phone: (225) 387-0999    
RSS LinkedIn Facebook

About the Firm

Kean Miller is counsel to the people and industries that drive the regional economy. From Fortune 1000 companies to local and regional businesses, we provide efficient and effective legal counsel in a cost-efficient manner. In the courtroom and the boardroom, Kean Miller attorneys create unique solutions, provide practical strategies, and deliver unparalleled value that allows our clients to perform at the highest level. Learn more.

Privacy PolicyDisclaimer
Copyright ©2022, Kean Miller LLP All Rights Reserved.
Law blog design & platform by LexBlog LexBlog Logo